I was disappointed when I received the boots (in black) - they look a bit 'cheap' (i.e. the outside leather) + the insoles do not seem to be as good than the ones I have with my other 3 pairs of Naot's. However, I would recommend the boots to someone who likes a very casual (reminds me of motorcycle boots) look + who experiences very wet and cold winters (there is a fabric liner throughout the boot to keep your feet toasty). The sizing is appropriate but the boots fit a bit snugger than the Naot Cruise. I hope this helps.